How to Make Yogurt


February 24, 2011 by Leah

Hi! Thanks for stopping by. Here’s an update (as of August 5, 2011) to the following post.


The principle of yogurt making is very simple: take some milk, heat it to kill the bacteria that’s already in it, cool it just enough so that it won’t harm the bacteria you plan to introduce, introduce said bacteria, and allow the whole shebang to ferment for a few hours at a friendly temperature. Voila. Creamy deliciousness. That said, the practice of making yogurt varies a lot from person to person.

This NYTimes article got me interested in yogurt-making last summer. I made my first batches of yogurt in a thermos, and while it worked, it wasn’t ideal. Eventually I came across the water bath method (I can’t remember where) and this has worked really well for me.

What you need:

  • Milk that has not been ultra-high pasteurized. It will say UHP on the label. Horizon Organic and other national brands are UHP. Trader Joe’s organic is not.
  • Yogurt from a previous batch or some plain yogurt from the store with live active cultures. I started with Trader Joe’s Greek-style plain yogurt last summer. (Can you tell there’s a Trader Joe’s up the street?)
  • A mason jar or two (with lids), depending on how much yogurt you want.
  • A large pot.
  • A cooler.
  • A thermometer is helpful, but if you don’t have one you can use other means to test the temperature of the milk; the milk hits 180 a few minutes after the water starts boiling if it’s come straight out of the refrigerator, and it is cool enough and ready for the live active cultures at or a little above human body temperature, so when you can stand to touch it.

Yogurt-making supplies

First, fill a couple of mason jars with milk. Set them in a pot of water. Heat the milk to about 180 degrees (I’ve tried lower temperatures and gotten runny yogurt). My thermometer has an alarm, so I can leave the yogurt unattended until it hits 180.

Heating the milk

Once the yogurt is heated, remove the jars from the pot and reserve the hot water in a cooler. This part always makes me feel like Faust.

Hot water goes into the cooler

Let the milk cool to between 90-120 degrees F. For the impatient among us, an ice bath makes this happen quickly.

Ice bath (for the impatient)

Remove the jars from the ice bath and add the ice water to the hot water in the cooler. Add a dollop of yogurt from your previous batch to each of your jars of milk, stir, and put the lids on the jars.

Adding yogurt from previous batch

The water in the cooler should be somewhere around 90-110 degrees (this happens magically when you mix the hot water and the ice water). Put your sealed jars in the cooler, pop the lid on, and leave for anywhere from 5-8 hours.

All cozy and starting to ferment

You can check on your yogurt after about five hours and if it looks more liquid than you’d like, leave it in for another hour or so. I usually end up leaving mine in for about eight hours, or even overnight when I forget about it.

Once your yogurt is done, you can eat it straight, mix it with fruit or honey, or (my favorite) use it as an accompaniment to food. It’s a great sour cream substitute. I had yogurt with all three meals yesterday: on oatmeal, with borsch for lunch, and with biryani for dinner.

Cool, creamy yogurt on spicy biryani. Mmm.

To make labneh (pictures here), or yogurt cheese, you just need to dump one of your jars of yogurt into some cheesecloth and either hang it for a while (overnight is good) and let the whey drip off, or put the cheesecloth into a sieve and let the whey drip off that way. (Save the whey, it can come in handy.) Labneh is delicious on toast, fruit, frittatas, and apparently you can even use it to make cheesecake. I use it in recipes in place of cream cheese or goat cheese.

To make more complicated cheese, I defer to Ricki the Cheese Queen of the New England Cheesemaking Supply Company. I ordered the 30 Minute Mozzarella and Ricotta Kit. I don’t make this kind of cheese often, because just buying mozzarella is cheaper and easier than using a gallon of milk, half an hour, and getting a lot of dishes dirty to make not-very-much mozzarella (and a whole ton of whey). If I ever get my goat farm or backyard cow I expect to become much more interested in cheese-making.

UPDATE: I had my first yogurt-making drama today, March 26th. Well, actually, the drama started when I let my yogurt hang out in the fridge for two weeks instead of the usual week, which I think killed or substantially weakened the live active cultures. Last week’s batch of yogurt tastes fine but is so runny it’s not worth much. So today, I went and bought an extra quart of milk and a starter culture (by which I mean a tub of plain Greek yogurt). I was making two quarts of yogurt, and everything was going fine until the cooling process, when the temperature differential between the ice water and the hot jar of milk caused the glass jar to break. I was aware this could happen, but it never had before. Also, if you’re going to break a glass, doing so in a contained environment (like a big metal cooking pot) is the way to go. (I break a glass about once every week or so.) But, if you’re going to use boiling water and then an ice bath, it is probably a good idea to let the jars cool down in the open air for several minutes in between.


13 thoughts on “How to Make Yogurt

  1. Kristina says:

    1. Awesome! It seems so doable now! Must show David.
    2. Love your spoon rest!

  2. David says:

    Thanks for the info. Now I just need to find a source of milk that has not been homoginized.

  3. leahkathlyn says:

    Homogenization shouldn’t actually matter too much for successful yogurt-making, although it’s way more fun to have non-homogenized milk because then you can separate the cream and make butter and such. You should be able to find milk that’s just pasteurized and not ultra-high pasteurized at the grocery store. If you want to take the plunge into raw milk for whatever reason, check out – apparently you can buy and sell it in Georgia as long as it’s labeled “for pet consumption only.”

  4. […] The Frugal Twosome You'd think we would have learned this stuff by now… Skip to content HomeAbout ← How to Make Yogurt […]

  5. lahancock says:

    Thank you for the pictorial. I am going to make yogurt soon. Maybe this weekend. I love your thermometer too, that would be very handy with the kiddos around.

    • leahkathlyn says:

      I use the thermometer for bread, too – just stab it into a loaf that’s in the oven and walk away until it hits 190. It’s so nice. (it was actually Aaron’s before we got married!)

  6. […] The principle of yogurt making is very simple: take some milk, heat it to kill the bacteria that's already in it, cool it just enough so that it won't harm the bacteria you plan to introduce, introduce said bacteria, and allow the whole shebang to ferment for a few hours at a friendly temperature. Voila. Creamy deliciousness. That said, the practice of making yogurt varies a lot from person to person. This NYTimes article got me interested in yog … Read More […]

  7. David G says:

    I am making my first batch of yogurt today. About a month ago I found a local source for raw milk. She had not been selling all of it, 5-6 gallons a day, so this last time she let me have 2.5 gallons that were 6-7 days old (not bad, but not long to go). So I am making butter (done), Butter milk (in progress), Yogurt (in progress), cottage cheese (done), and doing lots of cooking with milk. I have never had 4 gallons of milk in the house at once! (3 gallons from this trip, plus 1/2 gallon from my last visit and 1/2 gallon pasteurized for Kristina to drink)

  8. leahkathlyn says:

    Awesome. I’m making yogurt today, too. I haven’t done cottage cheese but I’d like to because I LOVE it. I’m always sad by how the ratio of whey to finished product seems so high when making cheeses, though.

  9. David G says:

    You can make ricotta from the whey. It does not make a lot, but every little bit of tasty nutrition you can get out of it sounds good to me. For leftover whey, that you don’t use fermenting grains or making bread, you can use it to water the garden or potted plants.

  10. lisa says:

    great post with the pictures and detail – thanks for posting this! what’s the model/brand on your thermometer? i’ve bought two from different stores and neither will allow me to set a cooling temp – only a high temp. Frustrated!

    • Hi, Lisa! My thermometer has since broken, so I have no idea what brand it was. Also, it only had a heating alert, no cooling alert (as I learned the hard way). It takes a long time for the milk to cool (I was having some trouble with broken jars using the ice bath method) so I usually just leave it be and then test whether it’s cool enough using my skin temperature.

  11. […] writing this very popular post, I’ve changed my yogurt-making methodology substantially. First, I started having some […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: